A Local's Guide to the Best Seafood in Fayetteville, NC

Fayetteville, NC is one of the most overlooked cities when it comes to culinary excellence. As the city is home to military personnel from all over the US, restaurants must compete to satisfy an array of culinary expectations. This includes offering excellent seafood.

Residents in Fayetteville can expect to find fantastic seafood offerings. From succulent shrimp to rich crab dishes to fine sushi, Fayetteville has it all. Here is our guide to the best seafood restaurants in Fayetteville, NC.

316 Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill

316 Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill brings coastal class to Fayetteville's culinary scene. This restaurant specializes in both raw bar classics and a variety of cooked seafood specialties. Locals tend to appreciate this eatery's oyster selections. Patrons can enjoy their oysters raw, steamed, or creative presentations such as the Oyster Rockefeller.

Beyond oysters, this eatery also has fantastic crab cakes, salmon, scallops, and shrimp. This restaurant is recommended for those who have high seafood standards. Most of the seafood items are delivered fresh daily, and the atmosphere is somewhat upscale yet still comfortable.

Captain Jerry's Seafood

Captain Jerry's Seafood is a favorite amongst locals. The atmosphere is casual, and the portions are generous. The food could be described as a greasy spoon, as much of the menu is deep-fried deliciousness. Captain Jerry's serves classic choices such as popcorn shrimp, calamari, New England clam chowder, and crab legs. Most items are served fry basket style, and entrees are often paired with hush puppies and coleslaw. While primarily known for seafood, Captain Jerry's also has some of the best onion rings in town.

Umami

When it comes to the best sushi in Fayetteville, we would have to recommend Umami. This restaurant has a modern and contemporary take on the Japanese tradition of sushi. Patrons can enjoy classical sushi and sashimi, or they can explore the dozens of unique roll options served at Umami.

Beyond sushi, Umami features a deep and expansive menu. Guests can also choose from udon noodles, teriyaki plates, and Japanese curry.

Pierro's Italian Bistro

While primarily known as an Italian restaurant, Pierro's Italian Bistro has some delightful seafood offerings that are worth your consideration. This bistro masterfully blends fresh seafood with classic Italian dishes. A notable standout is the Seafood Pierro's, an array of mussels, tiger shrimp, and bay scallops that is sauteed in either creamy alfredo or traditional chardonnay butter reduction, all tossed with linguine that is cooked to al dente perfection.

Seafood lovers also praise the Salmon Picatta, Fra Diavolo, and Seafood Risotto. Pierro's is somewhat upscale and sophisticated, making it the perfect place for a fun date night.

Hudson Bay Seafood

If you want your seafood prepared in a way that honors the traditions of southern soul food, we would like to introduce you to Hudson Bay Seafood. This family-owned restaurant is relaxed and welcoming, and earned a well-deserved reputation for having large portions and friendly staff. It's the perfect destination when craving comfort food. Diners particularly praise the fried fish and shrimp offerings.

The Juicy Crab

For those who want to roll up their sleeves and enjoy some authentic Cajun-style crab, we recommend The Juicy Crab. This eatery is all about customizing a feast. Patrons are invited to pick their fresh catch, be it Snow Crab Legs, lobster tail, clams, shrimp, mussels, or crawfish. Diners then select their sauce of choice, with the Juicy Sauce being the most popular. The spicy level can be adjusted, ensuring everyone can enjoy their boil of choice. This is the perfect place to go for a more unique dining experience.

If Cajun boils aren't your thing, the menu has plenty of other offerings. The Po-Boys and sliders are excellent, and the fried cheesecake is legendary.

Flying Legs

Sometimes you want seafood classics, other times you want bold and daring combinations. For the adventurous eater, we recommend Flying Legs. If you've ever wanted to pair crab legs with buffalo wings and sausage, Flying Legs is the spot for you. This restaurant features easy-to-share boils in addition to unique combos that you won't find anywhere else. It draws inspiration from culinary traditions from Cajun Country, the South, and the North, making it a perfectly unique option that can only be found in Fayetteville.

Move to the Best Seafood Restaurants in Fayetteville, NC and Move Into the Stone Ridge Apartment Homes

After learning about all the best Seafood Restaurants in Fayetteville, NC, you probably can't wait to move into a Fayetteville apartment. Stone Ridge Apartment Homes is a premier living community that balances comfort, style, and breathability. We offer a variety of floor plans, including 1,2, and 3-bedroom arrangements. Come to Stone Ridge Apartments to learn what life in Fayetteville, NC is all about.