Skip to main content

Foodie Finds in Fayetteville: 5 Best Downtown Restaurants

Fayetteville, NC, is a mid-sized city with a revitalized downtown with much to do for residents and visitors. With more than 200,000 people, Fayetteville has a thriving local economy. When it comes to restaurants, downtown Fayetteville has no shortage of them. 

From Southern comfort food to Italian cuisine, there's something for everyone. There are fast-food options and takeout places that offer delivery for a meal at home. There are also many eateries that offer full-service dining experiences.  

If you're looking for a new restaurant for a sit-down dining experience, here are the five best downtown restaurants in Fayetteville, NC. 

Foodie Finds in Fayetteville: 5 Best Downtown Restaurants

A group of people are gathered around a table eating food.

Antonella's Italian Ristorante 

Experience true Italian culture at Antonella's Italian Ristorante, a popular downtown restaurant in Fayetteville, NC, serving authentic Italian dishes. Since 2017, this restaurant, run by the daughter of Sicilian immigrants, has raised the bar for Italian cuisine in the area.  

Antonella's has a warm atmosphere with incredible staff and delicious food from start to finish. Start your experience with one of their appetizers, such as shrimp scampi, stuffed shrimp, classic tomato bruschetta, or their unique baked lasagna dip, which features meat sauce baked with cheese and fresh bread for dipping.  

For something lighter, try one of their salads. Whether you order their Greek salad, blue cheese wedge, spinach berry salad, or signature house Italian salad, you can expect fresh ingredients and flavor in every bite.  

For the main course, choose a pasta specialty, such as lasagna, ravioli portobella, or tortellini primavera. If you're avoiding carbs, some of their other signature specialties can satisfy your cravings without ruining your macro count. Try their eggplant Parmigiana, veal Calabrese, or chicken Parmigiana. They also offer gluten-free penne pasta and vegan options. 

Circa 1800 

This popular downtown restaurant in Fayetteville prioritizes seasonal ingredients, southern tradition, and thoughtful hospitality. They serve brunch, lunch, and dinner, making Circa 1800 a great choice for any time of the day. 

If you're visiting Circa 1800 for brunch, try one of their signature Southern options like shrimp and grits, stuffed French toast, smothered burrito, short rib grits, country-fried mac and cheese, or an omelet.  

Circa 1800's lunch menu consists of many delicious options. Some mains include a Southern fry basket, street corn tacos, chicken sandwich, burger, and fillet tips. For dinner, you'll find a large selection of starters, including seafood queso, BBQ oysters, BLT dip, and more. 

On their main menu, consider their flounder,  salmon curry, or pork chop served with mashed potatoes, green beans, stuffing, and cranberry mostarda. They also offer a variety of cocktails and red and white wines to go with your meal!  

A plate of fish and chips with a side of ketchup and lemon.

Gaston Brewing Restaurant 

This restaurant is veteran-owned, offering delicious food with quality local brew. Gaston Brewing Restaurant has an extensive menu, giving visitors a variety of dishes to consider. 

Start your dining experience with a shareable, such as their chips & queso, pretzel bites, fried cheese curds, or spinach & artichoke dip. From there, dive into a main dish, such as a sandwich or burger with fries. The Gaston Burger includes certified Angus beef topped with cheddar cheese, smoked bacon, onion straws, and Boondocker IPA BBQ sauce on a toasted bun. 

Other sandwich options range from crispy chicken to their Southern Bacon Jam burger. If you want something a little more substantial, try their oven-roasted 1/2 chicken, fish and chips, or chargrilled pork ribeye. They also have chicken tinga tacos, which they make with soft corn tortilla, slow-roasted pulled chicken, chipotle tinga sauce, cilantro, pickled onions, queso fresco, and chipotle ranch. Don't forget to check out their extensive drink menu if you want to enjoy the best local brews found in Fayetteville. 

Luigi's Italian Chophouse and Bar 

If you're ready for a taste of tradition, visit Luigi's Italian Chophouse and Bar.  Luigi's is an award-winning Italian restaurant in Fayetteville, NC, with a focus on high-quality cuisine and heartfelt hospitality. They specialize in homemade sauces, pan-sautéed pasta dishes, hand-cut black Angus steaks and chops, and fresh fish daily. 

For starters, try their Shrimp Santorini, 3-cheese pizza, or crab dip. For the main entree, consider their chicken with artichokes, which boasts a zesty lemon garlic sauce and mushrooms. If you prefer red meat, you can't go wrong with their ribeye steak or New York strip steak, topped with savory sauteed mushrooms .If you're in the mood for seafood, they have local scallops from Wanchese, NC, served seared with dill-infused butter.  

One of their most popular dishes comes from their Classico Italiano menu section. Here you'll find authentic dishes, such as eggplant Parmigiana, veal, baked penne, and fettuccine alfredo. 

A dish of spaghetti with shrimp and parsley on a grey surface.

Blue Moon Cafe 

Known for its craft food selection and hip environment, Blue Moon Cafe is one of the best restaurants in Fayetteville, NC. You'll find a variety of shareables, signatures, salads, entrees, and more on their menu. Many people will recommend their Cubano, made with ham, pork, pickles, honey Dijon mustard, and Swiss cheese on ciabatta.  

If you're interested in one of their signature dishes, try the Blue Moon Nachos, made with queso, pico de gallo, cheddar cheese, and chipotle ranch. Vegetarians will love their Root Veggie Tacos. They’re filled with black beans, sweet potato, tomato, onion, greens, purple cabbage, elote crema, cilantro, and queso fresco. 

Blue Moon Cafe also has a brunch menu, including seasonal French toast options, breakfast tacos, and a chorizo burrito. Also, don't forget to try one of their cocktails. Cocktail options include a passionfruit margarita, reverse martini, made with dry vermouth and just a splash of vodka, and a sweet, refreshing strawberry negroni. 

Live Close to Your Favorite Foodie Finds 

If you want to live close to the best downtown restaurants, then Stone Ridge Apartments might be the place for you! Our community offers 1-, 2-, and 3-bedroom homes with spacious open floor plans. We're pet-friendly, so your beloved dogs and cats are welcome here!  

You'll also enjoy some of the best amenities in the area, such as our resort-style pool with an expansive sundeck, an enclosed dog park, and an on-site fitness center. When you stay in for dinner, you'll appreciate the efficient appliances, ample counter space, and dishwasher for easy clean-up! If you're ready to upgrade your home,  schedule your tour today to see Stone Ridge Apartments in person.